If one of your important business services failed tomorrow, could you show that your firm would remain within its impact tolerance? 

For payment and e-money firms within scope of the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) operational resilience requirements, demonstrating resilience in practice is now a key regulatory expectation. Since 31 March 2025, the FCA has expected firms within scope to have completed sufficient mapping and testing. They should also have invested enough to remain within their impact tolerances. 

This applies to certain firms authorised or registered under the Payment Services Regulations 2017 and the Electronic Money Regulations 2011.  

Below, we set out what good looks like and the practical steps to close the gap between resilience on paper and resilience in practice. 

How to identify important business services

Strong operational resilience starts with correctly identifying your important business services. These are the services where disruption could cause intolerable harm to consumers or pose a risk to market integrity. 

Payment institutions and e-money institutions should define these services from the customer’s perspective. If your list reads like your organisational chart or IT inventory, it probably reflects how your firm is structured rather than what customers actually receive. 

Good practice: each important business service is clearly defined, with a documented rationale for why it is important. The firm revisits that assessment as the business changes. 

How should firms set impact tolerances?

An impact tolerance needs a clear rationale, not just a timeframe. If you set a four-hour tolerance, you should be able to explain why disruption beyond four hours would become intolerable. 

When setting tolerances, consider: 

  • the number and type of customers affected; 
  • transaction volumes and values, and outstanding transactions; 
  • potential financial and non-financial harm; and 
  • the impact on customers in vulnerable circumstances. 
     

Recent FCA observations reinforce that firms should not rely solely on time-based measures. 
 

Poor practice: adopting an existing IT recovery time objective as the impact tolerance, without considering the harm to consumers or the market. 

Mapping critical dependencies and third-party risks

Effective mapping identifies the people, processes, technology, facilities, information and third parties that support each important business service. But many critical dependencies sit further down the chain, in fourth parties, group services, shared platforms or infrastructure outside your direct control. 

To keep your mapping meaningful, we recommend: 

  • tracing each important business service end to end, including your key suppliers’ own critical dependencies; 
  • identifying concentration risks and single points of failure, and recording how each would affect the service; 
  • updating mapping whenever you change payment processor, launch a new product or see transaction volumes rise materially; and 
  • using mapping outputs to design scenario tests, so testing targets the weaknesses mapping reveals. 

 

Operational resilience scenario testing: what does good practice look like?

Testing only the scenarios you already know you can manage may produce reassuring results. But it tells you little about how the business would cope with more challenging disruption. 

Instead, test severe but plausible scenarios that genuinely stretch the business. These could include cyber incidents, data disruption, third party failure, loss of key staff or disruption hitting several important business services at once. 

For example, imagine your primary payment processor becomes unavailable during peak transaction volumes, while access to reconciliation data is also disrupted. The test should assess whether customers can continue to transact, whether manual workarounds can operate effectively under pressure and whether affected customers can be identified and informed. 

Where you cannot recover within the impact tolerance, the test should also show how you would prevent, minimise or delay intolerable harm. That means knowing the minimum service you can maintain, which customers or transactions to prioritise and how to limit harm. 

 

Addressing operational resilience vulnerabilities and testing improvements

Testing and mapping only add value if they lead to action. Identified vulnerabilities should have clear ownership and an agreed response, whether through remediation or formally documented risk acceptance, supported by appropriate governance and review. 

In practice, firms should: 

  • keep a single log of open vulnerabilities, completed remediation and accepted risks, including who accepted each risk; 
  • prioritise remediation by the potential harm to customers and markets, rather than by how easy it is to fix; 
  • validate significant remediation before closing the action, and re-test the service where appropriate; and 
  • escalate overdue or slipping actions to senior management. 

Closing an action simply because you have implemented a change is not enough. What matters is whether the change has addressed the underlying vulnerability. 

 

Testing communication plans during operational disruption

Disruption is a communications challenge as much as a recovery one. Your plan should cover customers, employees, senior management, regulators and other key stakeholders. It should also set out how you will communicate if your normal channels are unavailable. 

Good practice: testing alternative channels, escalation routes and approval processes as part of scenario testing. 

Poor practice: a documented communications plan that the firm has never tested under realistic conditions. 

 

What should an operational resilience self-assessment include?

Your self-assessment should give the board and senior management a clear view of your current resilience position. It should not simply describe where you expect to be once planned investment is complete. 

A strong self-assessment should: 

  • explain your important business services, impact tolerances and key dependencies; 
  • summarise the testing completed and what it revealed; 
  • set out open vulnerabilities, remediation underway and the residual risks you are accepting; 
  • record the challenge the board provided, the decisions it made and how it prioritised investment; and 
  • draw on appropriate second- and third-line assurance. 

Board approval on its own does not demonstrate effective oversight. The self-assessment should show that the board has engaged with the findings, not just signed them off. 

 

Embedding operational resilience into business-as-usual operations

Operational resilience is not a compliance exercise to complete and file away. The 31 March 2025 deadline was a regulatory milestone, but maintaining operational resilience requires ongoing assessment, testing and improvement.  

In practice, that means important business services and impact tolerances grounded in real customer harm. It means mapping that keeps pace with the business, testing that challenges rather than reassures, and vulnerabilities that the firm fixes and verifies. And a self-assessment that provides the board with an accurate, evidence-based view of the firm’s resilience position. 

Ultimately, a framework that sets out what should happen when things go wrong does not demonstrate resilience. Your firm’s response to real disruption does. 

 

How fscom can support your operational resilience

fscom Compliance Maturity Specialists™ helps payment and e-money firms strengthen their operational resilience arrangements and demonstrate their effectiveness in practice. We work with firms to: 

  • identify vulnerabilities across important business services, impact tolerances, mapping and third party dependencies before they cause harm; 
  • assess whether arrangements work as intended, through objective challenge of testing, governance and self-assessments; and 
  • prioritise practical improvements, so investment goes where it most reduces risk to customers and the firm. 


Our independent reviews provide firms with a clearer understanding of their resilience position and the practical improvements needed to strengthen their arrangements.
 

To discuss an independent review of your operational resilience arrangements, contact our team.