One of the most important lessons from fscom’s 2025 and 2026 safeguarding audits is that a control can exist without being sufficiently evidenced. Since 7 May 2026, CASS 15 has made that distinction much harder to overlook.

Why gaps developed under the legacy framework 

The legacy framework required robust controls, but firms had considerable discretion over how those controls were documented and evidenced. In practice, this could contribute to differences between stated arrangements, documented procedures and operational evidence. 

That flexibility sometimes allowed gaps to develop between: 

  • what the firm said it did; 
  • what its policy described; 
  • how its systems and processes actually operated; and 
  • what evidence could be retrieved during an audit; 

What our audit findings show 

Our 2026 Safeguarding Benchmarking Report reflects this. Across 28 safeguarding audits, first-line governance generated 34 of the 77 findings, more than any other review area. Five of these were rated high impact.  

Recurring issues included: 

  • safeguarding risk assessments that lacked granularity; 
  • policies that no longer reflected current practice; 
  • incomplete acknowledgement letters or breach registers; and 
  • limited evidence of board oversight. 


Some risk assessments identified only a small number of high-level risks or relied on scoring methodologies that were not clearly defined. In other cases, policies still referred to accounts, processes or fund flows the firm no longer used.
 

The individual issue might appear documentary, but the regulatory concern is wider. 

Each issue may look like a documentation problem, but the regulatory concern is wider. A firm must be able to clearly explain how it identified a risk, how the corresponding control operates, and why it considers the residual risk acceptable. Without that, it will struggle to demonstrate that its organisational arrangements are effective. 

How CASS 15 raises the bar 

CASS 15 reduces the scope for these differences to persist by setting more detailed expectations for how firms document, monitor and evidence their safeguarding arrangements. 

The FCA has described the Supplementary Regime as supporting more consistent record keeping and strengthening monitoring and reporting. Firms must maintain adequate arrangements to safeguard clients’ rights and prevent relevant funds being used for the firm’s own account. They must also allocate responsibility for operational compliance to a single director or senior manager of sufficient skill and authority. That person reports to the governing body.  

In practice, this changes the standard firms must meet. 

  • A safeguarding policy that broadly describes the correct outcome will provide limited assurance if the underlying fund-flow diagram is outdated. A risk register will be difficult to rely upon if its scoring methodology is unclear or if the risks identified do not reflect the firm’s actual products, counterparties and payment chains. 
  • A board cannot demonstrate effective oversight simply by receiving confirmation that “safeguarding is operating as expected”. It needs sufficiently detailed management information to understand exposures, reconciliation differences, breaches and remediation. 


The regulatory question is no longer simply:
Do you have a safeguarding control? It is: Can you demonstrate, through reliable and retrievable records, that the control is appropriately designed, consistently operated and effective? 

What we are seeing in practice

Take an e-money institution that added a second safeguarding bank to support its growth. Its finance team performs daily reconciliations across both accounts and resolves differences promptly. The control works. 

However, the safeguarding policy still describes a single account, and the fund-flow diagram predates the change. Reconciliation sign-offs sit in individual inboxes rather than a central record. When the auditor asks for three months of evidence, the team spends days reconstructing it. Two resolved breaks have no record of escalation. 

Client funds were never at risk. Yet the firm cannot readily show that its control operated as intended. Under CASS 15, that is the gap that matters. 

Testing your evidence chain

Six months into the new rules, firms should have considered an evidence-led review of their safeguarding framework: 

  1. Select a material safeguarding risk.
  2. Identify the regulatory requirement and control addressing it.
  3. Confirm that the risk assessment clearly explains the risk and the control. 
  4. Compare the policy and procedure with current operational practice. 
  5. Retrieve evidence that the control operated effectively over a defined period. 
  6. Confirm that exceptions were identified, escalated and resolved. 
  7. Check that the resulting management information reached an appropriate governance forum. 


If you cannot reconstruct that chain, your firm may have a control in practice but still face difficulty demonstrating compliance in upcoming audits.

The key takeaway

CASS 15 is more than just a new set of rules. It sets a clearer standard for how firms evidence the design, operation and oversight of their safeguarding arrangements. A control you cannot evidence is a control you will struggle to rely on. 

How fscom can help

fscom Compliance Maturity Specialists™ supports payment and e-money institutions with CASS 15 safeguarding audit readiness, gap analyses and framework reviews. We help firms test whether their policies, risk assessments, reconciliations and MI work together as a connected evidence chain. We then identify practical steps to close any gaps. 

Explore the findings in our 2026 Safeguarding Benchmarking Report  to see how your firm’s compliance maturity compares, or get in touch with our team to discuss a safeguarding review.